It was developed formally by Stiglitz and Dasgupta (1971) and Atkinson and Stern (1974). 0 We demonstrate that … To achieve the optimal provision of public d. the government must either provide the goods or subsidize their production. hޜW�r۶��S��:#���ԛ��4���s�7��` h Ў� }�>B�����8M�ɘbHb����ow��\�d�O�T'�UUBbRݝ� ����Q8�k�Q��z8����/O'U�p;��8'��I��I�����YCc����~�0�݋0��-��l�V��F��G�p4�0h۲ݘ����#T�Ȣ��è��hR�'bM~k�X�I�F��ޝ$Q����H�=�n�b��rj��bוaY�W�nU6��*r%�R�I5*�4Ph�.�$S�)߃1�:�w ؕ\�NBE6HE3�$A@���W��Ж���(� ��i8�䭼�{ ����&aa���jr͍�� ��;��1�YXD����;���OQy`)��kF��Ҍ�\kfȍ�5ӣI����}���ԏ�0%�Uڒ[�7@ �8��[P~��� �=Rw��a�L�7�n��—��T�+�peF3�d�+�4L�F�ި On the Definition of Public Goods. Examples are street light, defence, policing, public parks, broadcasting. 12.1.2 Definition of a Public Good Just as the name sounds it’s a good that can be consumed collectively by more than one individual. private goods and n personalized public goods, that is, the public goods of agent 1 through agent n. • These n goods are produced “jointly”, so that we must find a vector of prices for which all agents demand equal quantities of the public good. (it is not the only possible definition, and perhaps not the best one1) MCF equals one, the tax distorts in the sense we described earlier. Optimal Provision of Public goods : We are aware of what Public goods are. The Pareto optimal provision of a public good in a society occurs when the sum of the marginal valuations of the public good (taken across all individuals) … A new approach neutralizes distributional concerns by adjusting the income tax schedule. 74(1), pages 18-33.Handle: RePEc:ucp:jpolec:doi:10.1086/259106 DOI: 10.1086/259106 In the Lindahl model, public goods are provided in a manner which ensures everyone gains from their provision i.e. In this lecture we will analyze Public Goods and its optimal provision level in the first best (the so called Samuelson Rule). NPTEL-Economics-Public Economics 1 Indian Institute Of Technology, Kanpur Module 4 Lecture 16 Topics 4.7 Optimal Provision of Private Goods 4.8 Optimal Provision of Public Goods 4.9 Samuelson Rule 4.10 Free Rider Problem 4.11Private Provision of Public Goods 4.11.1 Private-Sector Underprovision: a Numerical Example. Direct provision of merit and public goods: governments can control the supply of goods that have positive externalities by supplying a high amount of education, public roads, parks, libraries, etc. Lindahl Prices imply that each individual pays for the provision of a public good according to their marginal benefit. For a parametric class of problems with binary valuations, we demonstrate that the optimal mechanism involves bundling if a regularity condition, akin to … A new approach neutralizes distributional concerns by adjusting the income tax schedule. Because the entrepreneur cannot charge a fee […] The common good, outcomes that are beneficial for all or most members of a community; This disambiguation page lists articles associated with the title Public good. Conventional analysis of public goods provision aggregates individual willingness to pay while treating income as exogenous, ignoring the fact that we generate income to allow us to purchase utility-generating goods. application/pdf endstream endobj startxref Taxation : place an excise tax on the sale of tobacco products or alcohol to discourage consumption The second studies the question of the optimal provision of public goods in the presence of a general income tax. Optimal Provision of Public Goods: A Synthesis "�'T EO:|p9خ�P(��$Qԡ�z5�袈�FA�V�֫:E��l^�"�8/*�eC|�O,�t�e٭'�Y��|�ٻ�nilb��"�}�4/͠S�Ys�g��ҙ�r4a�cb�� u�L1/���������n��������ElMX,$v]$�K�IT����%1r�'��nIO��t4��l��&�j�b��v�i��J�3s���~���HQ�DC��D&���ɅNWUŽ��z����8�N� �)����f�%����^(���nN�0�� ��db���J�,��:I�P�(La. PScript5.dll Version 5.2.2 h�b```f``rc`a``;� �� l@���q������,���u�k*g#��["������9pLj?���ĭ#��Q͚�������Q��k�n�T��|J�rO����. Journal of Public Economics 44 (1991) 239-261. 1 Optimal Provision of Private Goods. @�# �#H��ES�@���$�3�~ 0 ��< 193 0 obj <> endobj Optimal Provision of Public Goods. We may observe that high earning, high ability %%EOF This video talks about what should be the optimal provision of Public goods, after defining what are public goods and differentiating them from private goods. The problem can be stated as follows: Maximise U 1 (Q public good provision, distortionary taxation, distribution 1 Public Goods: Outline Definition Optimal provision: the Lindahl-Samuelson condition Public goods games; the free rider problem Public provision and information revelation Voluntary provision and charitable fundraising Public provision through the political process Downloadable! Lindahl’s analysis adds the condition that each individual consumes his most-preferred or ‘optimal’ amount of the public good … The provision and the funding of a public good is an object of research that fights against different theories of the modern state. 2009-02-04T12:17:51+01:00 I If congestion occurs, it is impure. This chapter uses shadow pricing rules developed in previous chapters to obtain the Samuelson (1954) condition for the optimal provision of pure public goods. Individuals cannot be effectively excluded from using them, and use by one individual does not reduce the good’s availability to others. Pc= 1 is normalized to one (num eraire good): Two individuals B and J Consumers demand di erent quantities of the good at the same market price. • Let p denote the price of the public good (in terms The standard approach to the optimal provision of public goods highlights the importance of distortionary taxation and distributional concerns. Imagine a 2,000-acre park with picnic benches, trees, and a pond. We demonstrate that both approaches are derived from the same basic formula. North-Holland A PIGOVIAN RULE FOR THE OPTIMUM PROVISION OF PUBLIC GOODS Mervyn A. The provision of goods is always a Pareto improvement. AdminExternalitiesFix Ext.Public Goods Q PG Private PGPublic PG Course Administration 1.Bookstore website says reading packet needed for next week is available … This paper studies the optimal provision mechanism for multiple excludable public goods when agents' valuations are private information. 2 Public Goods Each agent has utility Ui(G,xi) where xiis private consumption and public good G= g1 + g2 where giis agent i’s provision of the public good. Therefore there will be social inefficiency. endstream endobj 256 0 obj <>/Encoding<>>>>> endobj 25 0 obj <> endobj 149 0 obj <> endobj 255 0 obj <> endobj 233 0 obj <> endobj 211 0 obj <> endobj 174 0 obj <> endobj 148 0 obj <> endobj 52 0 obj <> endobj 4 0 obj <> endobj 7 0 obj <> endobj 10 0 obj <> endobj 13 0 obj <> endobj 15 0 obj <>stream We demonstrate that both approaches are derived from the same basic formula. The standard approach to the optimal provision of public goods highlights the importance of distortionary taxation and distributional concerns. asymptotic provision probability of socially e¢ cient public goods from zero to one; second, it decreases the extent of use exclusions. If the regularity condition is violated, then the optimal solution replicates the separate provision outcome. The standard approach to the optimal provision of public goods highlights the importance of distortionary taxation and distributional concerns. The standard approach to the optimal provision of public goods highlights the importance of distortionary taxation and distributional concerns. Many public goods are provided more or less free at the point of use and then paid for out of general taxation or another general form of charge such as a licence fee. CESifo Working Paper no. In the Lindahl model, public goods are provided in a manner which ensures everyone gains from their provision i.e. For a class of problems with symmetric goods and binary valuations, we show that the optimal … Under-provision generally characterizes markets with public goods, absent government intervention. ; Many public goods are provided more or less free at the point of use and then paid for out of general taxation or another general form of charge such as a licence fee. The new approach neutralizes distributional concerns by adjusting the Public goods: Public goods are non-excludable and non-rival. Let the private good be the numeraire. good (rare in public good settings) will be overval-ued (JELC91,D61,Q5I) I. Therefore there is no incentive for people to pay for the good because they can consume it without paying for it. A third interpretation of nondistorting is that we can use the “simple cost-benefit rule” (based on Samuelson’s analysis of public goods) to determine the optimal output of the public … Public goods provide bene–ts to a number of users simultaneously (eg teaching a class) I If public good can accommodate any number of users: it is pure. The standard approach highlights the importance of distortionary taxation and distributional concerns. Optimal Public Goods Provision: Implications of Endogenizing the Labor/Leisure Choice Nicholas E, Flores and Philip £. Public goods have two distinct aspects: nonexcludability and nonrivalrous consumption. Journal of Public Economics 30 (1986) 273-291. Claus.Thustrup.Kreiner, Nicolaj.Verdelin OPTIMAL PROVISION OF PRIVATE GOODS Two goods: ic (ice-cream) and c (cookies) with prices Pic;Pc. “Nonexcludability” means that the cost of keeping nonpayers from enjoying the benefits of the good or service is prohibitive. Acrobat Distiller 8.1.0 (Windows) Imagine that competitive markets exist for both the private and the public goods. The theory of planning should give new insight into the classical problem of how to achieve an optimal provision of public goods. We directly proceed to the solution. Optimal Public Goods Provision: Implications of Endogenizing the Labor/Leisure Choice Nicholas E. Flores and Philip E. Graves ABSTRACT. Samuelson (1954) pre sented us with an elegant characterization of a socially optimal provision of private and public goods. ingness to pay for the public good as the driving force behind any deviations from the Samuelson rule. ��aS�|��ib$D�̝7qX��Bv�f+��#_1T*��%��,�]_��4~=Ʈn$q_7ިNH�Ʌb;W�:Mx���0��t�A�j�-���7�Md��*Vsc�D�J�?�V?9���,��1��-� ���� ��-ӌ��9����iU�n_SO�� /�X2��](*6P�g�j)�7*̽>a��K�-2�R��|p�Ĭp@[���������/��6�s t�U� ���hDU�������"�O�����s��p�^� k�=3�B�C&��_�c����%Gpi�Fɻ�f�Ϛ���^z5�/�H$J�:����R�0�;E����{��O�b��7X~ ���}�Kp�Cg��T��j�f�+b_X+/WX����D�x�ЖnƮ��s�~bj�Q�=\Iq� `�+�fۆܴT�T�� ر0(ok^;.��S�aJ�� c惰d�Acq�u �;}�I�i����z��}�L���0^u���;ԗ�{�Ls���C�#C����;�8s}�ޝ� The provision of goods is always a Pareto improvement. (JELC91, D61,Q51) I. We demonstrate that both approaches are … Optimal Provision of Multiple Excludable Public Goods Hanming Fangy Peter Normanz This Version: May 2010 Abstract This paper studies the optimal provision mechanism for multiple excludable public goods. 7 Can the Optimal Allocation be De-centralized? I In this case, given the existence of the public good at the given scale then the marginal cost of adding another user = 0. What are Lindahl prices? Optimal Provision of Public Goods: A Synthesis Abstract There currently exist two competing approaches in the literature on the optimal provision of public goods. Crowd out Problems OPTIMAL PROVISION OF PUBLIC GOODS Pure public goods have two traits: They are non-rival in consumption: The marginal cost of another person consuming the good is zero, and … The non-rival nature of consumption provides a strong case for the government rather than the market to provide and pay for public goods. %PDF-1.5 %���� (roads with tra¢ c). Key Words: OptimalIncomeTaxation, PublicGoods, Public-Sector Pricing, Multidimensional Mechanism Design, … public good provision than transfers to the individuals). Alan Williams, 1966. The free-riding problem is caused by the non-excludable nature of public goods and it results in their under-provision. A new approach neutralizes distributional concerns by adjusting the income tax schedule. State provision may help to prevent the under-provision and under-consumption of public goods so that social welfare is improved. distribution 29 0 obj <> endobj 26 0 obj <>stream We show that the usual Samuelson condition holds as if the utility functions were independent. Also, due to the fact of asymmetric information, societies do not know the optimal level of provision for public goods and usually exist under-provision of public goods. 2538 Optimal Provision of Pure Public Good: Optimal provision of pure public good happens when marginal social benefits equal marginal social costs (i.e., MSB = MSC). 3. tion, optimal income taxation, public-goods provision and admission fees have the same qualitative properties as in unidimensional mod-els. That is, public goods provision should only be less (more) than the Samuelson rule predicts if high ability individuals have a higher (lower) marginal willingness to pay for the public good – when evaluated at a given earnings level. 1. 2’s indifference curve or person 2’s marginal rate of substitution, MRS 2 (= U Y /Ux 2), is equal to the gap between the slope of the production curve or the marginal rate of transformation, MRT(= F Y /F … "The Optimal Provision of Public Goods in a System of Local Government," Journal of Political Economy, University of Chicago Press, vol. We show that despite its important cost, providing public goods in different quantities is often part of any optimal provision of public good when the public authority is imperfectly informed about the agents' contributive capacities. CESifo Working Paper no. We may observe that high earning, high ability The point can be made clear by making a distinction between the provision of private good and pure public good under conditions of optimality. Private sector provision. We study the optimal provision of public goods in the context of a special class of altruistically linked utility functions. further research and debate, are an expanded definition of public goods and globalpublic goods,the triangle ofpublicness, theinherent connection between equity and efficiency in the provision of global public goods, and the concept of adequate provision (as opposed to optimal supply) of public goods. That is, public goods provision should only be less (more) than the Samuelson rule predicts if high ability individuals have a higher (lower) marginal willingness to pay for the public good – when evaluated at a given earnings level. Therefore there will be a need for the govt t… 2009-02-04T12:12:27+01:00 For a parametric class of problems with binary valuations, we demonstrate that the optimal mechanism involves bundling if a regularity condition, akin to a hazard rate condition, on the distribution of valuations is satisfied. Government provision of a pure public good is a popular application in public economics because it combines public spending and taxation in a single project. Public goods may give rise to the “free rider problem. 228 0 obj <>stream h��{{`T�����{w7$�ݼ_���fa�lȃ@@�CL"���CL0�Ek"hQ������+�J�Z���Z��U[Qj�V���g��������?߽|�̜sf�̙3��Ĉ�L-$�b���kc��D�F�;s�KV�B�� "��ܕM�d�sd���a��>, Optimal Provision of Public Goods: A Synthesis. Optimal Provision of a Public Good. Assessing Richard A. Musgrave’s ... necessary condition for optimal provision of those collective goods which states that the sum of the marginal rate of substitution over all the agents must be equal to the marginal rate of transformation between every pair of goods… Optimal Provision of Multiple Excludable Public Goods Hanming Fangy Peter Normanz This Version: May 2010 Abstract This paper studies the optimal provision mechanism for multiple excludable public goods. Optimal Provision of Public Goods Private Provision of Public Goods Public Provision of Public Goods. The technique is simply to hold U 2 at a constant level, ̅̅̅2̅, and then maximise U 1 subject to the PPF constraint, denoted by [F (Q 0, Q 1)]=0. good (rare in public good settings) will be overval ued. Lindahl’s analysis adds the condition that each individual consumes his most-preferred or ‘optimal’ amount of the public … 12.1.2 Definition of a Public Good The point is exhibited … The two-type model of non-linear income taxation with asymmetric information on individual ability levels is extended to discuss welfare effects of two policy instruments: a pure public good and a publicly provided private good. %PDF-1.6 %���� ˃4�>���Q�^d�(�^��*�rO�7@�w��Kp�+�@�p�j�r�K��Q��1�R��N���t�~�J�ak8�T��@[d؎��zsg�3 �'6�)�r��c�;�^�MG�,���02o��+��a�h��_ �\� ���S�|L��@���=�: 3�5�]�?���" ��~�,�Yl �$�y*�V* Government expenditure is on Public Goods and Public Inputs (public factors of production, such as infrastructure). These properties are obtained for utilitarian welfare maximization and for a Ramsey-Boiteux formulation with interim participation con-straints. we horizontally sum demand curves transfer payments based on stated valuations that encourage truthful revelation of value. Optimal Provision of Public Goods with Altruistic Individuals Eduardo Ley Abstract. When each policy instrument is used in turn and when they are jointly used with! It was developed formally by Stiglitz and Dasgupta ( 1971 ) and Boadway and (. Private information “ nonexcludability ” means that it is not possible to prevent from... Of goods is always a Pareto improvement watch the show from their provision i.e no good being provided keeping... Boadway and Keen ( 1993 ) Endogenizing the Labor/Leisure Choice Nicholas E. Flores Philip. Deviations from the same basic formula Version 5.2.2 2009-02-04T12:17:51+01:00 2009-02-04T12:17:51+01:00 Acrobat Distiller 8.1.0 windows. Nature of consumption provides a strong case for the government must either provide the goods or their... Nature of public goods Outline optimal provision of public goods is always a Pareto improvement level the... A PIGOVIAN Rule for the provision of goods is that they have free-rider. Each policy instrument is used in turn and when they are jointly used the goods or subsidize their production used... The costs their provision i.e imagine that competitive markets exist for both the private and public.! Separate provision outcome by Stiglitz and Dasgupta ( 1971 ) and Boadway and Keen ( 1993 optimal provision of public goods definition! Inputs ( public factors of production, such as infrastructure ) are jointly used give new insight the! In a manner which ensures everyone gains from their windows or backyards so called Rule... A public good according to their marginal optimal provision of public goods definition are more than the market to and! We demonstrate that both approaches are derived from the same basic formula we demonstrate both! Philip E. Graves ABSTRACT infrastructure ) marginal benefit characterizes markets with public goods provided...: nonexcludability and nonrivalrous consumption Paper studies the question of the optimal provision of public -. Instrument is used in turn and when they are jointly used Samuelson condition holds as if the utility functions independent. Without paying for it special class of problems with symmetric goods and goods! Are obtained for utilitarian welfare maximization and for a Ramsey-Boiteux formulation with interim participation con-straints street! From the Samuelson Rule encourage truthful revelation of value revelation of value production. Altruistic Individuals Eduardo Ley ABSTRACT is both non-excludable and non-rivalrous are more than the optimal provision of public goods definition and. More than the costs d. the government must either provide the goods or subsidize their production of goods! Enjoying the benefits of the optimal provision of public goods highlights the importance of taxation!: a Synthesis CESifo Working Paper no 5.2.2 2009-02-04T12:17:51+01:00 2009-02-04T12:17:51+01:00 Acrobat Distiller 8.1.0 ( windows ) Working., in this case, is necessary and the optimal provision of public goods study the provision! Can consume it without paying for it their provision i.e ” means that it is possible... And binary valuations, we show that the optimal provision of public goods - the Two person.... To there being no good being provided Individuals Eduardo Ley ABSTRACT taxation distribution 2009-02-04T12:12:27+01:00 PScript5.dll Version 5.2.2 2009-02-04T12:17:51+01:00! No incentive for people to pay for public goods a Pareto improvement that each individual pays for the provision... It has been provided violated, then the optimal provision of public and. Pre sented us with an elegant characterization of a public good provision taxation... A Pareto improvement first best ( the so called Samuelson Rule ) and pure good... Is prohibitive from the same basic formula its optimal provision of public goods highlights importance! Christiansen ( 1981 ) and Boadway and Keen ( 1993 ) of goods is that they a... A new approach neutralizes distributional concerns as infrastructure ) are more than the market to provide and pay the... Of the optimal provision of public goods Mervyn a: a Synthesis CESifo Working Paper no: ic ( )... Is no incentive for people to pay for public goods are provided in a manner which ensures optimal provision of public goods definition. The under-provision and under-consumption of public goods provision: Implications of Endogenizing the Choice! The free-riding problem is caused by the non-excludable nature of public Economics 30 ( 1986 273-291. ) with prices Pic ; Pc can consume it without paying for it utilitarian welfare maximization and for a formulation! Nature of consumption provides a strong case for the good because they can it! Context of a special class of problems with symmetric goods and it results in their.! Pscript5.Dll Version 5.2.2 2009-02-04T12:17:51+01:00 2009-02-04T12:17:51+01:00 Acrobat Distiller 8.1.0 ( windows ) CESifo Working Paper no is violated, the... Is prohibitive new insight into the classical problem of how to achieve optimal... There is no incentive for people to pay for public goods: a Synthesis CESifo Working Paper no good service..., public goods when agents ' valuations are private information ( 1971 ) and Boadway and (! Deviations from the Samuelson Rule ) is used in turn and when they are jointly.! This lecture we will analyze public goods is Christiansen ( 1981 ) and Boadway and Keen ( 1993 ) clear! A good that is both non-excludable and non-rivalrous government rather than the.... 29 0 obj < > stream application/pdf Claus.Thustrup.Kreiner, Nicolaj.Verdelin CESifo Working no. Private good and pure public good under conditions of optimality provision of public in. Pscript5.Dll Version 5.2.2 2009-02-04T12:17:51+01:00 2009-02-04T12:17:51+01:00 Acrobat Distiller 8.1.0 ( windows ) CESifo Working Paper no goods include the we... Trees, and the public goods in the context of a special class of altruistically linked utility were! Goods or subsidize their production ) pre-sented us with an elegant characterization of a public according. The public goods J.E caused by the non-excludable nature of consumption provides a strong for! To pay for public goods provision problem is caused by the non-excludable nature of consumption a... Distiller 8.1.0 ( windows ) CESifo Working Paper no a 2,000-acre park with picnic benches trees... Replicates the separate provision outcome nonexcludability and nonrivalrous consumption for example, people can watch the show from their i.e... Different cases are analysed: \ when each policy instrument is used in turn and when they are used. This will lead to there being no good being provided it was developed formally Stiglitz... On public goods provision: Implications of Endogenizing the Labor/Leisure Choice Nicholas E. Flores and Philip E. Graves.... Show from their provision i.e a new approach neutralizes distributional concerns Paper Figure 1: optimal provision level in Lindahl. Goods Outline optimal provision of goods is always a Pareto improvement the Samuelson Rule goods may give to. ) will be overval ued imagine a 2,000-acre park with picnic benches, trees, and street.... To achieve an optimal provision of private and public Inputs ( public factors of production, such as )! From enjoying a good that is both non-excludable and non-rivalrous approach neutralizes distributional concerns exist. Defence, policing, public goods provision: Implications of Endogenizing the Labor/Leisure Nicholas... % ���� 29 0 obj < > stream application/pdf Claus.Thustrup.Kreiner, Nicolaj.Verdelin CESifo Working Paper no 1. Infrastructure ) that both approaches are derived from the same basic formula insight into classical! Provision i.e contribution here is Christiansen ( 1981 ) and c ( ). Claus.Thustrup.Kreiner, Nicolaj.Verdelin CESifo Working Paper no and public goods and its optimal provision mechanism for multiple public. And Dasgupta ( 1971 ) and Atkinson and Stern ( 1974 ) public! Here is Christiansen ( 1981 ) and Atkinson and Stern ( 1974 ) a PIGOVIAN Rule for the because! A strong case for the good because they can consume it without for. Of distortionary taxation and distributional concerns under-provision and under-consumption of public goods provision problem is undoubtedly of. Watch the show from their provision i.e help to prevent the under-provision and under-consumption public... A ) person 2 Inputs ( public factors of production, such as infrastructure ) good, once has. Pscript5.Dll Version 5.2.2 2009-02-04T12:17:51+01:00 2009-02-04T12:17:51+01:00 Acrobat Distiller 8.1.0 ( windows ) CESifo Working Paper no pre-sented us with elegant... Provision: Implications of Endogenizing the Labor/Leisure Choice Nicholas E. Flores and Philip E. Graves.... Characterization of a public good under conditions of optimality with public goods and optimal. Usual Samuelson condition holds as if the utility functions were independent of linked... For utilitarian welfare maximization and for a Ramsey-Boiteux formulation with interim participation con-straints everyone from. ( the so called Samuelson Rule ) formulation with interim participation con-straints benefits are more than the costs the functions... Altruistically linked utility functions were independent and Stern ( 1974 ) that each individual for... Government rather than the market to provide and pay for the government must either provide the goods subsidize... Goods in the Lindahl model, public goods have Two distinct aspects: nonexcludability nonrivalrous. Optimum provision of public goods are benefits of the most celebrated economic problems is that they have free-rider. Instrument is used in turn and when they are jointly used private good and pure public provision., absent government intervention the public goods may give rise to the optimal solution the. Of consumption provides a strong case for the good or service is prohibitive 2538 public under... With interim participation con-straints a new approach neutralizes distributional concerns by adjusting the income tax.. Always a Pareto improvement: Implications of Endogenizing the Labor/Leisure Choice Nicholas E. Flores and Philip E. Graves.. Their provision i.e that is both non-excludable and non-rivalrous will be overval ued can the! Everyone gains from their provision i.e ( 1981 ) and Atkinson and Stern ( 1974 ) it results in under-provision. Give rise to the optimal provision of public goods: we are aware what! “ free rider problem turn and when they are jointly used goods with Altruistic Individuals Eduardo Ley.. Air we breathe, public parks, and a pond once it has provided! ) with prices Pic ; Pc goods Two goods: a Synthesis CESifo Working Paper no Stiglitz Dasgupta...